COMPLETE VICTORY: Eyman beats Ferguson in court — judge sides w/me on Carbon Tax Initiative

Fri, July 2, 2021


The judge sided with me and agreed the AG’s ballot title for the Carbon Tax Initiative was biased and filled with loaded language.


Here’s how Ferguson had originally described the initiative:
This measure would prohibit state agencies, counties, and cities from imposing any “cap-and-tax scheme” unless required by uniform federal law, and repeal certain state laws creating a “cap-and-invest program” to limit greenhouse-gas emissions.


And after listening to my arguments and the AG’s defense on Friday, the judge issued her ruling this week. Her legal conclusion was that Ferguson’s description was biased against the initiative and changed it to the alternative I had suggested:


This measure would prohibit state agencies, counties, and cities from imposing any cap and tax scheme not required by uniform federal standard, and repeal 2021 legislation creating such a scheme.


This is a complete victory, not just for this initiative, but for future initiatives.


Because Ferguson’s corruptive practice of helping his political allies and sabotaging his political enemies has been exposed and because of this ruling, it’ll be harder for him to do that going forward.


And how much did this victory cost our supporters?




I’m not an attorney — I’m an activist — so my hourly rate is $0.


All I ask is for you to help me continue to do what I was born to do by donating to my legal defense fund so I can appeal the ridiculously unconstitutional restrictions on the First Amendment and $5.5 million fine imposed on me.


Mail your check to: Tim Eyman Legal Defense Fund, 500 106th Ave NE #709, Bellevue, WA, 98004
Or donate by: Paypal

Or: Debit Card or Credit Card


I am so grateful to the thousands of people who have helped me and my family survive the government’s 8 1/2 year political persecution. Please continue with that assistance.  



For background on this week’s victory against the AG, check out Monday’s update:


Mon, June 28, 2021


Initiatives are written by citizens.


The AG writes the descriptions (called ballot titles).


Bob Ferguson is the most corrupt AG in WA state history.


If he supports an initiative (like anti-gun Initiative 1639) he puts his thumb on the scale and makes sure the official ballot title is biased in favor of the measure.


When he opposes the initiative ($30 Tabs), he sabotages them.



He wrote a totally biased description for our NO CARBON TAX INITIATIVE.


So I challenged him in court — the hearing was on Friday.


I sent out a last minute invitation (one hour before the hearing!!) for supporters to join me there.


One did.


She sent me this over the weekend: 


“A prepared, poised, and articulate Tim Eyman took on the AG’s Office today at the Thurston County Superior Court. At stake was the issue of the AG’s proposed biased ballot title description of the NO CARBON TAX INITIATIVE. Fortunately for the voting citizens, Tim’s concise and well-spoken arguments throughout the proceedings were even complimented by an appreciative Judge Amamilo.



Tim’s rebuttals to the AG’s arguments were a particular highlight! Thinking on his feet, under that kind of pressure, was impressive. Judge Amamilo’s immediate agreements with Tim included taking out proposed wording that did not appear anywhere in the initiative (“repeal cap and invest program to limit greenhouse gas emissions”) and likewise taking out loaded language that was clearly intended to undermine Tim’s/our initiative. The Constitutional concerns that Tim clarified in his steadfast arguments clearly resonated with the judge, and were so compelling that she said she was going to research them carefully because she deemed them so important that she wanted “to get it right”. Tim politely asked when a ruling from her was expected. She responded that it would be by this Tuesday. She went out of her way to compliment Tim for his politeness, professionalism, and brevity. I consider it a privilege to have attended and witnessed Tim in action and to see a judge in Thurston County be so diligent and respectful of her duty to “get it right.” After the hearing, I asked Tim some questions and he thanked me profusely for being there. I asked him if it was OK to recap what I saw so he could share it with everyone. We are so lucky to have a fierce, smart, experienced fighter like Tim willing to challenge the establishment in court, in the Legislature, and in the streets with initiatives.” Myrna Lee Hilmo, Olympia


For me, the most gratifying moment was when the judge said “I saw those words in the title (limit greenhouse gas emissions) and frankly I was surprised to see them in there, that the AG put those in there.”


After the hearing, I was floating:





As you know, I’m in a political death match with the Attorney General who is hell-bent to destroy me and stop us. 



Please help me appeal these ridiculously unconstitutional restrictions on the First Amendment and continue fighting for taxpayers.



Please donate to my legal defense fund here:


Mail your check to: Tim Eyman Legal Defense Fund, 500 106th Ave NE #709, Bellevue, WA, 98004
Or donate by: Paypal

Or: Debit Card or Credit Card


In addition, we worked really hard on our $30 Tabs Initiative:



Karen and I sacrificed a lot — we sold off our retirement fund to kickstart its signature drive:


And now, a message from Sid Maietto and Larry Jensen:


We’re asking folks to donate to our PAC so Tim can get paid back and to help stop Inslee’s Income Tax and Carbon Tax Schemes with the initiatives we’re co-sponsoring with Tim.





The taxpayers of Washington need our help now more than ever. Donate to our political committee so we can keep fighting for you:


Mail your check — made payable to “Permanent Offense” — to: Permanent Offense, PO Box 6151, Olympia, WA, 98507
Or donate by: Paypal
Or by: Debit Card or Credit Card


Kindest Regards, 



Sid Maietto & Larry Jensen


— END —


Thanks everyone.


I love you all.